Chapter 3: Problem 9
In what kind of pot will a given volume of water boil at a higher temperature: a tall and narrow one or a short and wide one? Explain.
Short Answer
Expert verified
Answer: A short and wide pot allows water to boil at a higher temperature compared to a tall and narrow pot due to its increased surface area and better heat distribution.
Step by step solution
01
Understand the concept of boiling temperature
Boiling temperature is the temperature at which a liquid's vapor pressure equals the pressure exerted upon it by its surroundings. In the case of water, its boiling point is 100°C (212°F) at standard atmospheric pressure (1 atm). However, the boiling temperature of water can be slightly affected by factors such as the shape of the pot and heat distribution.
02
Analyze the heat distribution in the pots
Heat distribution plays a critical role in the boiling temperature of water. A pot with better heat distribution will transfer heat more efficiently across its surface, allowing the water to heat up evenly and reach boiling temperature faster. A tall and narrow pot will have a smaller bottom surface area compared to a short and wide pot. As a result, heat distribution is likely to be less efficient in a tall and narrow pot, potentially leading to a lower boiling temperature.
03
Consider the surface area of the pots
The surface area of a pot also contributes to the boiling temperature of water. Larger surface area allows more heat to get absorbed by the water, raising its temperature more rapidly. A short and wide pot has a larger surface area than a tall and narrow pot, making it more efficient in transferring heat to the water.
04
Combine the observations and make a conclusion
Based on the analysis of heat distribution and surface area, it can be concluded that a short and wide pot allows water to boil at a higher temperature compared to a tall and narrow pot. The increased surface area and better heat distribution in a short and wide pot lead to more efficient heating, which in turn results in a higher boiling temperature for the water.
Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!
-
Full Textbook Solutions
Get detailed explanations and key concepts
-
Unlimited Al creation
Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...
-
Ads-free access
To over 500 millions flashcards
-
Money-back guarantee
We refund you if you fail your exam.
Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with Vaia!
Key Concepts
These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.
Heat Distribution
Heat distribution refers to how evenly heat is spread throughout a substance or across a surface. In the context of boiling water, even heat distribution is essential for reaching the boiling point efficiently. When heat is applied to the bottom of a pot, the goal is to transfer this heat to the water inside as uniformly as possible.
The design of the pot is crucial in this process. A tall and narrow pot may concentrate heat at the base, while the upper parts may not receive as much, leading to uneven heating of the water. This can cause 'hot spots' at the base, with the water at the top being cooler, which might delay the process of reaching an overall boiling temperature. On the other hand, a short and wide pot has a greater bottom surface area directly in contact with the heat source, promoting a more uniform temperature rise throughout the water volume. This means that the heat supplied is more effectively utilized to increase the water's temperature, reducing the time to reach a boil.
The design of the pot is crucial in this process. A tall and narrow pot may concentrate heat at the base, while the upper parts may not receive as much, leading to uneven heating of the water. This can cause 'hot spots' at the base, with the water at the top being cooler, which might delay the process of reaching an overall boiling temperature. On the other hand, a short and wide pot has a greater bottom surface area directly in contact with the heat source, promoting a more uniform temperature rise throughout the water volume. This means that the heat supplied is more effectively utilized to increase the water's temperature, reducing the time to reach a boil.
Surface Area Effect
The surface area effect is intimately connected to how heat transfer occurs and influences the boiling temperature of water. With a greater surface area in contact with the heat source, more heat can be absorbed at any given time. A pot with a larger base will spread the heat over a wider area, thus heating more water simultaneously.
A short and wide pot, which has a larger bottom surface, can absorb more heat and distribute it across the entire volume of water more effectively than a tall, narrow pot. This accelerated heat absorption not only shortens the time it takes for the water to begin boiling but can also potentially increase the boiling temperature. The effectiveness of heat transfer is, in part, a result of maximizing the surface area that is in direct contact with the heat source, thus optimizing the boiling process.
A short and wide pot, which has a larger bottom surface, can absorb more heat and distribute it across the entire volume of water more effectively than a tall, narrow pot. This accelerated heat absorption not only shortens the time it takes for the water to begin boiling but can also potentially increase the boiling temperature. The effectiveness of heat transfer is, in part, a result of maximizing the surface area that is in direct contact with the heat source, thus optimizing the boiling process.
Vapor Pressure
Vapor pressure is a measure of the pressure exerted by a vapor in thermodynamic equilibrium with its condensed phases at a given temperature in a closed system. When it comes to boiling water, the temperature at which water boils is the point at which its vapor pressure equals the surrounding environmental pressure. This means that, inside a pot of water, when the water molecules at the surface have enough energy to break free from the liquid state and form gas, boiling occurs.
However, the ease with which water molecules can escape the liquid's surface and create vapor can be influenced by the container's shape and surface area. The energy distribution within the water influences how quickly the vapor pressure can reach the critical point for boiling. A larger surface area means more space for water molecules to escape, which can accelerate the boiling process.
However, the ease with which water molecules can escape the liquid's surface and create vapor can be influenced by the container's shape and surface area. The energy distribution within the water influences how quickly the vapor pressure can reach the critical point for boiling. A larger surface area means more space for water molecules to escape, which can accelerate the boiling process.
Environmental Pressure Impact
The impact of environmental pressure on the boiling temperature of water is a critical aspect of physical chemistry and must be considered when discussing boiling points. At standard atmospheric pressure (1 atm), water boils at 100°C (212°F). Changes in environmental pressure, such as those at higher altitudes, directly affect the boiling temperature. Lower atmospheric pressure at higher elevations means that water can reach the boiling point at a lower temperature.
In the context of our pot comparison, while both pots are subjected to the same environmental pressure, it is the way each pot manages the heat transfer that can cause variations in how quickly they reach the boiling point. The pot design does not change the principle that water's vapor pressure must match the surrounding pressure to boil, but it can affect the temperature uniformity, impacting the energy that molecules must overcome before vaporization.
In the context of our pot comparison, while both pots are subjected to the same environmental pressure, it is the way each pot manages the heat transfer that can cause variations in how quickly they reach the boiling point. The pot design does not change the principle that water's vapor pressure must match the surrounding pressure to boil, but it can affect the temperature uniformity, impacting the energy that molecules must overcome before vaporization.