Warning: foreach() argument must be of type array|object, bool given in /var/www/html/web/app/themes/studypress-core-theme/template-parts/header/mobile-offcanvas.php on line 20

Consider the case of a symmetrical double well, such as the one pictured in Figure. We are interested in Figure 8.13bound states with E<V(0) .
(a) Write down the WKB wave functions in regions (i) x>x2 , (ii) x1<x<x2 , and (iii) 0<x<x1. Impose the appropriate connection formulas at and (this has already been done, in Equation 8.46, for x2 ; you will have to work out x1 for yourself), to show that


ฯˆ(x)={DPxexp-1hโˆซx2xpx'dx'2DPxsin1hโˆซx2xpx'dx'+ฯ€4DPx2cosฮธ1hโˆซvx1pxdx+sinฮธe1hโˆซvx1pxdx

FIGURE 8.13: Symmetrical double well; Problem 8.15.
Where

ฮธโ‰ก1hโˆซx1x2p(x)dx .

(b) Because v(x) is symmetric, we need only consider even (+)and odd (-)wave functions. In the former case ฯˆ(0)=0 , and in the latter case ฯˆ=(0)=0 . Show that this leads to the following quantization condition:

tanฮธ=ยฑ2ef.

Where

fโ‰ก1hโˆซ-x1x1p(x)dx

Equation 8.59determines the (approximate) allowed energies (note that Ecomes into 1 and x2, so ฮธ and ฯ• are both functions of E ).

(c) We are particularly interested in a high and/or broad central barrier, in which case ฯ• is large, and eฯ•is huge. Equation 8.59 then tells us thatA ฮธmust be very close to a half-integer multiple of ฯ€ . With this in mind, write localid="1658823154085" (ฮธ=n+1/2)ฯ€+o . where localid="1658823172105" |โˆˆ|<<1, and show that the quantization condition becomes

localid="1658823190448" ฮธ=(n+12)ฯ€m12e-f.

(d) Suppose each well is a parabola: 16

localid="1658823244259" v(x)={12mฯ‰2x+a2,ifx<012mฯ‰2x-a2,ifx<0 .

Sketch this potential, find (Equation 8.58 ), and show that

localid="1658823297094" Enยฑ=(n+12)hฯ‰mhฯ‰2ฯ€e-f

Comment: If the central barrier were impenetrable localid="1658823318311" (fโ†’โˆž) , we would simply have two detached harmonic oscillators, and the energies, localid="1658823339386" En=(n+1/2)hฯ‰ , would be doubly degenerate, since the particle could be in the left well or in the right one. When the barrier becomes finite (putting the two wells into "communication"), the degeneracy is lifted. The even (localid="1658823360600" ฯˆn+) states have slightly lower energy, and the odd ones ฯˆn. have slightly higher energy.
(e) Suppose the particle starts out in the right well-or, more precisely, in a state of the form

localid="1658823391675" ฯˆ(x,0)=12(ฯˆn++ฯˆn)

which, assuming the phases are picked in the "natural" way, will be concentrated in the right well. Show that it oscillates back and forth between the wells, with a period

localid="1658823416179" ฯ„=2ฯ€2ฯ‰e.

(f) Calculate , for the specific potential in part (d), and show that for , localid="1658823448873" V(0).>>E,ฯ•~mฯ‰a2/h.

Short Answer

Expert verified

Therefore,

(a) ฯˆWKBxโ‰ˆDpxexp1hโˆซx2xpx'dxDpxsin1hโˆซx2xpx'dx+ฯ€4Dpx2cosฮธePx'dx+sinฮธe-1hโˆซxx1pxdx'
(b) ฯ•=1/ฤงโˆซ-x1xp(x')dx.

(c)ฮธโ‰ˆn+12ฯ€+12e-ฯ• .
(d) En+=n+12ฤงฯ‰+ฤงฯ‰2ฯ€e-ฯ•.
(e) ฯ„=2ฯ€2ฯ‰eฯ•.

(f) ฯ•~mฯ‰a2ฤง is showed.

Step by step solution

01

(a) By using wave function. 

Write down the WKB wave functions in regions (i) x >x2, (ii) x1>x>x2and (iii) <x<x1. Impose the appropriate connection formulas at x1and x2, to show that

ฯˆWKBxโ‰ˆDpxexp1hโˆซx2xpx'dxDpxsin1hโˆซx2xpx'dx+ฯ€4Dpx2cosฮธePx'dx+sinฮธe-1hโˆซxx1pxdx'

The WKB wave function takes the form,

ฯˆWKBxโ‰ˆDpxexp1hโˆซx2xpx'dxDpxsin1hโˆซx2xpx'dx+ฯ€4

To do the same thing for the turning point , we will follow the same procedure. But first let's rewrite localid="1658393003007" ฯˆWKB. (ii) in such a form that help us effectively join it with ฯˆWKB. (iii) atX1. Using the definition of Equating 9.59, we rewrite the WKB wave function in region (ii) as

ฯˆWKBxโ‰ˆ2Dpxsin-1hโˆซx1xpx'dx'ฮธ+ฯ€4

The next step then is to patch the WKB solutions (in regions (ii) and (iii)) at. Let us shift the axes over so that the turning pointoccurs at, then we have

ฯˆWKBxโ‰ˆ-2Dpxsin1hโˆซx2xpx'dx-ฮธ-ฯ€4,x>01pxFe1nโˆซx0Px'dx+Ge-1hโˆซxx1pxdx'X<0 โ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆ ()

The turning pointsx1has a downward slope, so the patching wave function, in this case, assumes the form

ฯˆpx=aAi-ax+bBi-axโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆ ( 2)

Where a=2mV0/h21/3, and also, the momentum, in this case, takes the following form:

px=ha3/2x

.

02

In particular, for x<0.

For,

โˆซx0px'dx'โ‰ˆั›a3/2โˆซx0-x'dx'=23ั›-ax3/2

And therefore the WKB wave function (Equation (1)) can be written as

ฯˆWKBxโ‰ˆ1ha3/4-x1/4Fe23-ax3/2+Ge-23(-ax)3/2

Meanwhile, using the large- z asymptotic form of the Airy function for large positive z (remember thatz=-ax), the patching wave function (Equation (2)), for x<0, becomes

ฯˆpxโ‰ˆ1ฯ€-ax1/4a2e-23-ax3/2+be23-ax3/2

Comparing the WKB and patching wave functions in the region where x<0 , we find

a=2ฯ€าปaGand b=ฯ€ั›aF โ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆ(3 )

03

In particular, for x>0.

For x>0 , we have

โˆซ0xP'xdx'ฤงa3/2โˆซ0xxโˆซ0xP'xdx=23ฤงax3/2

and therefore the WKB wave function (Equation ()) can be written asฯˆWKBXโ‰ˆ-2Dฤงa3/4x1/4sin23ax3/2-ฮธ-ฯ€4ฯˆWKBXโ‰ˆ-2Dฤงa3/4x1/4cos23ax3/2+ฯ€4-ฮธ

Let ฮฒโ‰ก2/3ax3/2+ฯ€/4, then using elementary trigonometry,

ฯˆWKBXโ‰ˆ2Dฤงa3/4x1/4cosฮฒcosฮธ+sinฮฒsinฮธ

Meanwhile, using the large-z asymptotic form of the Airy function for large negative z (remember that z=-ax ), the patching wave function (Equation (2)) x>0 , for becomes

localid="1658823967085" ฯˆpxโ‰ˆ1ฯ€ax1/4asinฮฒ+bcosฮฒ

(In terms ofฮฒ). Comparing the WKB and patching wave functions in the region where x>0, we find

aฯ€=2DฤงasinฮธAnd bฯ€=2Dhacosฮธ

Or, putting in Equation (3) for and :

G=DsinฮธAnd F=2Dcosฮธ

These are the connection formulas, joining the WKB solutions at either side of the turning point . Expressing everything in terms of the one normalization constant D , and shifting the turning point back from the origin to an arbitrary point x1, we show that the WKB wave function in the three regions (i), (ii) and (iii) is

localid="1658824119486" ฯˆWKBxโ‰ˆDpxexp-1hโˆซx2xpxdx'2Dpxsin1hโˆซxx2px'dx+ฯ€4DpxI2cosฮธe1rโˆซxx1px'dx+sinฮธe1rโˆซxx1px'dx' โ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆ(4)

Where,

ฮธ=1/ฤงโˆซx1x2pxdx

04

(b) Odd wave function with quantization condition.

Let's start by the easy case; the oddwave functions. It requiresฯˆ0=0.


(iii) (Equation (4)), we have

localid="1658402848392" sinฮธe-1rโˆซ0x1pxdx'=-2cosฮธ1rโˆซ0x1px'dx

(AssumingDโ‰ 0), which leads to

tanฮธ=-2e1rโˆซ0x1px'dx

tanฮธ=-2e1rโˆซ0x1px'dx

Where the second equality is valid by the virtue of symmetry of v(x) (remember that ) Ipxi=2mIE-vxI. Introducing whose definition is given by Equation 9.61, we can write

tanฮธ=-2eฯ•

Consider the case of even (+) wave functions. This requiresฯˆ0=0. The derivative ofฯˆWKB(region (iii) in Equation (4)) is

ฯˆWKBx=-12IpxIdIPxIdxฯˆWKBx+DIpxI2cosฮธe1rโˆซxx1px;dx-1hIpxI+sinฮธe1rโˆซxx1pxdx1hIpxI................. ( X)

At X=0 , the first term vanishes by the fact that

dIPxIdxx-0=ddx2mVx-EX-OdIPxIdxx-0=mV'02mV0-E=0

(Indeed V(0)=0since V(x) since is symmetric). Thus ฯˆWKB0=0 (Equation ( 5)) leads to

-2cosฮธeฯ•/2+sinฮธe-ฯ•/2=0

tanฮธ=2eฯ• (Or)

Putting the results together, we see that the requirementsฯˆ0=0andฯˆ0=0leads to the following quantization condition:

ฯ•=1/hโˆซ-xx1px'dx โ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆ ()

Where,

ฯ•=1/ฤงโˆซ-x1x1px'dx'.

05

(c) Using quantization condition.

The quantization condition (equation (6)), withฮธ=n+1/2ฯ€+owhereo<<1, becomes

tann+1/2ฯ€+tano1-tann+1/2ฯ€tano=ยฑ2eฯ•

Dividing the numerator and denominator of the fraction on the lefttann+1/2ฯ€by and realizing thatan(n+$$1/2)ฯ€โ†’โˆž, the equation reduces to

-1tanoโ‰ˆ1o=ยฑ2eฯ• (or) o=ยฑ12e-ฯ•

Expressing the result in terms ofyields the following form of quantization condition:

ฮธโ‰ˆn+12ฯ€+12e-ฯ• โ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆ (7 )

06

(d) Sketch the graph by using V(x).

Figure shows the sketch of the potential V (X) . Since the right-side parabola (for X>0 ) is symmetric about X=A and the integration limits X1and X2are equidistant from a , then we can write

ฮธ=2hโˆซax2pxdx

Where the turning pointX2satisfies,

E=Vx2=12mฯ‰2x2-a2โ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆ.. (8 )

In this case,

px=2mE-1/2Mฯ‰2x-a2px=mฯ‰x2-a2-x-a2

Thus,

ฮธ=2mฯ‰hโˆซax2x2-a=x-a2dx

By using the substitution, u=x-a , this integral simply appears to be the area of a quarter circle with radius x2-a, which is trivial to calculate:

ฮธ=2mฯ‰hโˆซ0x2-ax2-a2-u2duฮธ=ฯ€mฯ‰2hx2-a2ฮธ=ฯ€hฯ‰E

(Equation ( 8)), and the quantization condition (Equation (7 )) yields

n+12ฯ€ยฑ12e-ฯ•=ฯ€hฯ‰ENยฑ

(Or)

Enยฑ=n+12hฯ‰+hฯ‰2ฯ€e-ฯ• โ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆ.(9)

To sketch a symmetric double parabola V(x).

07

(e) Sketch the graph.

Suppose the particle starts out in the right well that is a state of the form

ฯˆฯ„=ฯˆx,0=12ฯˆn++ฯˆN-

It is also useful to define the state in which the particle resides in the left well;

ฯˆฯ„=12ฯˆN+-ฯˆN-

At arbitrary time, the state of the particle (tacking on the phases in the natural way) evolves to

ฯˆx,t=12ฯˆn+e-iEn+tir+ฯˆn-e-iEn-tirฯˆx,t=12e-En+tirฯˆn++ฯˆn-e-ist

Where we define localid="1658464326203" ฮดโ‰กEn--EN+IฤงIt follows that

Iฯˆx,tI2=12ฯˆn+2+ฯˆn-2+ฯˆn+ฯˆn-eist+e-ist

We used the fact and are real functions (see Equation (4 )). Since eist+e-ist/2=cosฮดt(Euler's formula), we can write

Iฯˆx,tI2=12ฯˆn+2+ฯˆn-2+2ฯˆn+ฯˆn-cosฮดt

Here we notice something remarkable. Att =0

Iฯˆx,02=12ฯˆn++ฯˆn-2Iฯˆx,02=ฯˆr2

The particle starts out at the right well (as expected).localid="1658467491416" Att=ฯ€/ฮด

localid="1658467501051" ฯˆx,ฯ€/ฮด2=12ฯˆn+-ฯˆn-2ฯˆx,ฯ€/ฮด2=ฯˆ2

The particle hops into the left well. Atlocalid="1658467510407" t=2ฯ€/ฮด, the particle jumps back again into the right well, and we see the particle keeps oscillating back and forth between the wells, with a period

localid="1658467528233" t=2ฯ€ฮด=2ฯ€ฤงEn--EN+=2ฯ€2ฯ‰eฯ•

To sketch for localid="1658467548354" ฯˆe+and localid="1658467540229" ฯˆe- (for x<0 ).

To sketch for ฯˆe+ and ฯˆe-(for ).

To sketch the probability density att =0

08

(f) To evaluate the integral of.

The specific potential in part (d) is symmetric, and so we need to deal only with the right parabola well then we double the answer. In this case (for x>0),

Ipx=2mIE-12mฯ‰2x-a2IpxI=mฯ‰x1-a2-x-a2

Where the turning pointsx1satisfies,

E=12mฯ‰2x1-a2

Thus,

ฯ•=2mฯ‰hโˆซ0x1a-x2-a-x12dx

This integral can be done using the change of variables,a-x=a-x1coshฮธ. It follows (check the answer yourself!)

ฯ•=mฯ‰ahy2yy2-1-Iny+y2-1

Where yโ‰กaIa-x1>1.

For V(0)>>E, that is a2>>x1-a2, or y2>>1,

localid="1658824827027" ฯ•~mฯ‰a2hy2y2-2In2y~mฯ‰a2ฤง

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with Vaia!

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

For spherically symmetrical potentials we can apply the WKB approximation to the radial part (Equation 4.37). In the case I=0it is reasonable 15to use Equation 8.47in the form

โˆซ0r0p(r)dr=(n-1/4)ฯ€h.

Where r0is the turning point (in effect, we treat r=0as an infinite wall). Exploit this formula to estimate the allowed energies of a particle in the logarithmic potential.

V(r)=V0In(r/a)

(for constant V0and a). Treat only the case I=0. Show that the spacing between the levels is independent of mass

Use the WKB approximation in the form

โˆซr1r2p(r)dr=(n-1/2)ฯ€h

to estimate the bound state energies for hydrogen. Don't forget the centrifugal term in the effective potential (Equation ). The following integral may help:

โˆซab1x(x-a)(b-x)dx=ฯ€2(b-a)2.

Note that you recover the Bohr levels whennโ‰ซ/andnโ‰ซ1/2

Use the WKB approximation to find the allowed energies of the general power-law potential:

V(x)=ฮฑ|x|vwhere v is a positive number. Check your result for the case v=2 .

Derive the connection formulas at a downward-sloping turning point, and confirm equation8.50.

ฯˆ(x)={D'|p(x)|exp-1hโˆซxx1|p(x')|dx'.ifx<x12D'p(x)sin-1hโˆซx1xp(x')dx'+ฯ€4.ifx<x1

Consider a particle of massm in the n th stationary state of the harmonic oscillator (angular frequency ฯ‰ ).

(a) Find the turning point, x2 .
(b) How far (d) could you go above the turning point before the error in the linearized potential reaches 1%? That is, if V(x2+d)-VIin(x2+d)V(x2)=0.01 what is ?
(c) The asymptotic form of Ai(z) is accurate to 1% as long as localid="1656047781997" zโ‰ฅ5. For the din part (b), determine the smallest nsuch thatฮฑdโ‰ฅ5 . (For any n larger than this there exists an overlap region in which the liberalized potential is good to 1% and the large-z form of the Airy function is good to 1% .)

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Physics Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.

Sign-up for free