Chapter 7: Problem 37
Explain why the question T: Type of data-one variable or two? Categorical or numerical? is one of the four key questions used to guide decisions about what inference method should be considered.
Chapter 7: Problem 37
Explain why the question T: Type of data-one variable or two? Categorical or numerical? is one of the four key questions used to guide decisions about what inference method should be considered.
All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.
Get started for freeIn a study of whether taking a garlic supplement reduces the risk of getting a cold, 146 participants were randomly assigned to either a garlic supplement group or to a group that did not take a garlic supplement ("Garlic for the Common Cold," Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2009). Based on the study, it was concluded that the proportion of people taking a garlic supplement who get a cold is lower than the proportion of those not taking a garlic supplement who get a cold. a. What claim about the effect of taking garlic is supported by the data from this study? b. Is it possible that the conclusion that the proportion of people taking garlic who get a cold is lower than the proportion for those not taking garlic is incorrect? Explain. c. If the number of people participating in the study had been \(50,\) do you think that the chance of an incorrect conclusion would be greater than, about the same as, or lower than for the study described?
Should advertisers worry about people with digital video recorders (DVRs) fast-forwarding through their TV commercials? Recent studies by MillwardBrown and Innerscope Research indicate that when people are fast-forwarding through commercials they are actually still quite engaged and paying attention to the screen to see when the commercials end and the show they were watching starts again. If a commercial goes by that the viewer has seen before, the impact of the commercial may be equivalent to viewing the commercial at normal speed. One study of DVR viewing behavior is described in the article "Engaging at Any Speed? Commercials Put to the Test" (New York Times, July 3,2007 ). For each person in a sample of adults, physical responses (such as respiratory rate and heart rate) were recorded while watching commercials at normal speed and while watching commercials at fast-forward speed. These responses were used to calculate an engagement score. Engagement scores ranged from 0 to 100 (higher values indicate greater engagement). The researchers concluded that the mean engagement score for people watching at regular speed was \(66,\) and for people watching at fast-forward speed it was \(68 .\) Is the described inference one that resulted from estimation or one that resulted from hypothesis testing?
The concept of a "phantom smoker" was introduced in the paper "I Smoke but I Am Not a Smoker: Phantom Smokers and the Discrepancy Between Self-Identity and Behavior" (Journal of American College Health [2010]: \(117-125\) ). Previous studies of college students found that how students respond when asked to identify themselves as either a smoker or a nonsmoker was not always consistent with how they respond to a question about how often they smoked cigarettes. A phantom smoker is defined to be someone who self-identifies as a nonsmoker but who admits to smoking cigarettes when asked about frequency of smoking. This prompted researchers to wonder if asking college students to self-identify as being a smoker or nonsmoker might be resulting in an underestimate of the actual percentage of smokers. The researchers planned to use data from a sample of 899 students to estimate the percentage of college students who are phantom smokers.
To examine the effect of exercise on body composition, data were collected from a sample of active women who engaged in 9 hours or more of physical activity per week ("Effects of Habitual Physical Activity on the Resting Metabolic Rates and Body Composition of Women Aged 35 to 50 Years," Journal of the American Dietetic Association [2001]: 1181-1191). Percent of body fat was measured for each woman. The researchers planned to use the resulting data to learn about mean percent body fat for active women.
"Want to Lose More Fat? Skip Breakfast Before Workout" (The Tribune, June 4,2010 ) is the headline of a newspaper article describing a study comparing men who did endurance training without eating before training and men who ate before training. Twenty men were assigned at random to one of two 6-week diet and exercise programs. Both groups followed a similar diet and performed the same daily morning exercise routine. Men in one group did the exercise routine prior to eating, and those in the other group ate first and then exercised. The resulting data supported the claim that those who do not eat prior to exercising burn a higher proportion of fat than those who eat before exercising. Is the inference made one that involves estimation or one that involves hypothesis testing?
What do you think about this solution?
We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.