Question

What conclusion is supported by this statement about the interpretation of the Constitution? A. A document that needs amendments is not a reliable guide for government policy. B. A document that can be reinterpreted is not an adequate method for resolving legal questions. C. A text that causes controversy does more harm than good. D. Interpretations of the Constitution can change, which in turn affect decisions made by lawmakers.

Short answer

Option D is the most supported conclusion, as it directly refers to the statement's idea that changing interpretations of the Constitution can influence lawmakers' decisions.

Step-by-step solution

Consider the statement

The key element in this exercise is to consider the implications of the interpretations of the Constitution and how they can influence government decisions. This statement suggests that changes in interpretations can have a direct impact on the decisions made by lawmakers.

Evaluate Option A

Option A states that a document that needs amendments is not a reliable guide for government policy. This option discusses the reliability of a document that needs amendments but does not directly relate to the statement about the interpretation of the Constitution affecting lawmakers' decisions.

Evaluate Option B

Option B states that a document that can be reinterpreted is not an adequate method for resolving legal questions. Although this option seems more relevant than option A, it focuses on the adequacy of reinterpretation to resolve legal questions, rather than the influence of interpretation on lawmakers' decisions.

Evaluate Option C

Option C states that a text that causes controversy does more harm than good. This option focuses on the impact of controversy, rather than the effect of interpretations of the Constitution on lawmakers' decisions.

Evaluate Option D

Option D states that interpretations of the Constitution can change, which in turn affect decisions made by lawmakers. This option directly refers to the statement's idea that changing interpretations of the Constitution can influence lawmakers' decisions, making it the best match.

Choose the best conclusion

After evaluating all four options, we can conclude that Option D is the best match and is most supported by the statement about the interpretation of the Constitution given in the exercise.