Logout Open In App
Open In App
Warning: foreach() argument must be of type array|object, bool given in /var/www/html/web/app/themes/studypress-core-theme/template-parts/header/mobile-offcanvas.php on line 20

Chapter 7: Problem 2

Aramayo: Our federal government seems to function most efficiently when decision-making responsibilities are handled by only a few individuals. Therefore, our government should consolidate its leadership and move away from a decentralized representative democracy. Tello: But moving our government in this direction could violate our constitutional mission to provide government of, for, and by the people. Which of the following statements describes Tello's response to Aramayo? A. Tello contradicts the reasoning used by Aramayo. B. Tello uncovers an assumption used in Aramayo's reasoning. C. Tello brings up a possible negative consequence of accepting Aramayo's argument. D. Tello reveals the circular reasoning used by Aramayo. E. Tello shows that Aramayo overgeneralizes a very special situation.

Short Answer

Expert verified
C. Tello brings up a possible negative consequence of accepting Aramayo's argument.

Step by step solution

01

Understand Aramayo's Argument

Aramayo is suggesting that the federal government would function more efficiently if decision-making powers were centralized. He believes that reducing the number of decision-makers would streamline operations.
02

Understand Tello's Response

Tello responds by stating that moving towards a centralized form of government could jeopardize the democratic nature of government. She does not contradict Aramayo's reasoning, but rather brings up a potential negative outcome that could result.
03

Analyze the Options

Now, match Tello's response with the available choices. Option C, 'Tello brings up a possible negative consequence of accepting Aramayo's argument,' accurately represents Tello's response as she identifies a potential problem with Aramayo's suggestion without necessarily contradicting his reasoning.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Start your free trial

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with Vaia!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

Argument Analysis
Analyzing an argument involves breaking it down into components to see how each part contributes to the overall claim. In the case of Aramayo and Tello, Aramayo's argument is about centralizing government for efficiency, while Tello's response brings attention to the potential risks of such a change.
Steps to Analyze an Argument:
  • Identify the main claim or conclusion. Here, Aramayo claims that a more centralized government is more efficient.
  • Look for supporting reasons. Aramayo suggests that fewer decision-makers improve efficiency.
  • Consider possible counterarguments or negative impacts. Tello warns about the risk to democratic values.
Understanding these elements helps you evaluate the strength and implications of arguments in critical reasoning tasks.
Logical Reasoning
Logical reasoning is the process of using rational steps and evidence to arrive at conclusions. In critical reasoning, logic ensures arguments are coherent and persuasive.
Key Aspects of Logical Reasoning:
  • Sound Structure: A well-structured argument follows a logical sequence, making it easy to follow.
  • Evidence and Examples: High-quality explanations use valid evidence to support claims.
  • Recognizing Assumptions: Understanding implicit assumptions is vital. Tello identifies an assumption about efficiency versus democracy in Aramayo's argument.
By honing logical reasoning skills, students can critically assess arguments, distinguishing between a sound argument and one with flaws or gaps.
Negative Consequences
Negative consequences refer to the adverse effects or outcomes that might result from adopting a particular argument or action. Tello highlights the potential risk of centralizing the government.
Impacts of Negative Consequences:
  • Loss of Democratic Values: Tello argues that centralization could undermine the democratic principle of representation.
  • Reduced Public Participation: With fewer decision-makers, public engagement and input might diminish.
  • Potential Resistance: Changes that negatively impact democratic principles may face public opposition.
Discussing negative consequences is crucial in argumentation as it balances the potential gains with the risks involved, helping to make well-informed decisions.
Centralized Government
A centralized government is one where decision-making authority is concentrated among a small group of people or a single entity. Aramayo argues that this system increases efficiency.
Characteristics of a Centralized Government:
  • Unified Decision-Making: Decisions can be made quickly without many layers of approval.
  • Consistency in Policies: Policies are often more uniform because of centralized control.
  • Potential Downsides: Risks include reduced checks and balances and limited public input, as Tello mentioned.
Understanding centralized governments involves recognizing both potential benefits, like efficiency, and risks, such as reduced democratic engagement.
Democratic Principles
Democratic principles refer to the ideals that ensure a government represents and is accountable to its people. Tello emphasizes these principles when critiquing Aramayo's argument for centralization.
Understanding Democratic Principles:
  • Representation: Ensuring all voices are heard in policy making.
  • Public Participation: Citizens have the ability to influence decisions and elect leaders.
  • Accountability: Leaders are responsible for their actions and can be replaced through elections.
Tello's response underscores the significance of maintaining these democratic elements, arguing that shifting to a centralized system could threaten such governance ideals.

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

Business computer systems are designed to make workers more productive by automating a portion of the work that must be completed in a business process. As a result, the employee is free to perform more tasks that require human attention. Although productivity may be lost during a learning period, many businesses experience dramatic gains in productivity after installing a new computer system. While discussing the connection between productivity gains and computer systems, a well-respected business journal recently stated that the person who serves as the Chief Information Officer is the consummate business computer system. By comparing a Chief Information Officer to business computer systems, the journal implicitly argues that A. Chief Information Officers should always communicate the value of computer systems to their companies\ B. the productivity of a company can be increased through the hiring of a Chief Information Officer C. many companies have not improved their productivity with new computer systems D. Chief Information Officers are more effective than are new computer systems E. the impact of a Chief Information Officer on a company's productivity is difficult to measure

Whenever Joe does his laundry at the Main Street Laundromat, the loads turn out cleaner than they do when he does his laundry at the Elm Street Laundromat. Laundry done at the Main Street Laundromat is cleaner because the machines at the Main Street Laundromat use more water per load than do those at the Elm Street Laundromat. Which of the following statements, if true, helps support the conclusion above? A. The clothes washed at the Elm Street Laundromat were, overall, less clean than those washed at the Main Street Laundromat. B. Joe uses the same detergent at both laundromats. C. The machines at the Oak Street Laundromat use twice as much water as do those at the Main Street Laundromat. D. Joe does three times as much laundry at the Main Street Laundromat as he does at the Elm Street Laundromat. E. Joe tends to do his dirtier laundry at the Elm Street Laundromat

According to the United States Postal Service bureau of information, the rate of complaints concerning late delivery was 30 times higher in 1991 than in \(1964 .\) Because the United States Postal Service changed neighborhood routes from a multiple-truck delivery system to a single truck delivery system between 1964 and \(1991,\) the enormous increase in complaints must be a result of this systematic change. Which of the following, if true, weakens the conclusion drawn above? A. In \(1991,\) most late-mail complaints were reported to the appropriate United States Postal Service office, whereas in 1964 most were not. B. Even in a multiple-truck delivery system, certain letters will arrive late. C. According to the United States Postal Service bureau of information, most of the complaints concerning late delivery in 1991 were about registered mail. D. The bulk amount of mail processed by the United States Postal Service was not much larger in 1991 than it was in \(1964,\) before the systemic change occurred. E. The change in neighborhood routes from a multiple-truck to a single-truck delivery system sometimes causes enormous increase in the price of stamps.

In \(1989,\) corporate tax rates in some regions of the United States fell to their lowest level in 15 years, while the rates in other regions reached new highs. In \(1974,\) similar conditions led to a large flight of companies from regions with unfavorable corporate tax policies to regions with favorable policies. There was, however, considerably less corporate flight in 1989 Which of the following, if true about \(1989,\) most plausibly accounts for the finding that there was less corporate flight in \(1989 ?\) A. The regions with the most favorable corporate tax policies had many of the same types of corporations as did those with unfavorable tax policies, but this was not true in 1974. B. In contrast to \(1974,\) office rental costs in the regions with the most favorable corporate tax policies were significantly higher than rental costs in other areas of the country. C. In contrast to \(1974,\) in \(1989,\) the areas with the most favorable corporate tax policies reaped the most benefit from tax incentives, although the tax codes were particularly difficult to decipher. D. Tax incentives offered by foreign countries were higher in 1989 than in 1974. E. Individual tax incentives in the areas with favorable corporate tax policies were slightly lower than they were 15 years earlier in areas with favorable corporate tax policies.
See all solutions

Recommended explanations on English Textbooks

Pragmatics

Read Explanation

Graphology

Read Explanation

Summary Text

Read Explanation

Language and Social Groups

Read Explanation

Single Paragraph Essay

Read Explanation

Rhetoric

Read Explanation
View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.

Sign-up for free