Question

A man asks his brother for $\mathrm{\$}400$ to buy a television set. His brother gives him the money, and the man buys a television set. Is it guaranteed that the brother's $\mathrm{\$}400$ went to buy the television set? Why or why not?

Short answer

No, it's not guaranteed that the brother's $400 went to buy the television set because the source of the actual money spent on the television set isn't established in the question.

Step-by-step solution

Understand the Scenario

One must first comprehend the situation provided. A man requests money from his brother to purchase a television set. The brother provides the funds, and the man does buy a television set.

Analyze the Connection

Next, consider whether the brother's donation directly funded the television purchase. Could the man have used his own money? Could someone else have given him money as well? It's possible. There's no given evidence that the donated money went specifically to the television.

Form a Conclusion

Based on the provided information, it can't show conclusively that the brother's $400 directly funded the television set purchase. While it's likely, without further data, we're left to speculate.