Chapter 14: Problem 9
If \(G\) is a group and \(a, b \in G\), then \(b\) is a square root of \(a\) if \(b^{2}=a\). (i) Prove that every element of a cyclic group \(G\) has at most two square roots. (ii) Find a counterexample to (i) when \(G\) is not cyclic.
Short Answer
Expert verified
(i) Proof: Elements in cyclic groups have at most two square roots. (ii) Counterexample: Klein four-group \(V_4\) where identity has four square roots.
Step by step solution
01
Understand Cyclic Groups
A cyclic group, denoted as \(G\), is a group that can be generated by a single element. That means every element in \(G\) can be expressed as a power of a specific element \(g\), the generator. Thus, any element \(a\) in a cyclic group can be written as \(a = g^k\) for some integer \(k\).
02
Identify the Square Root Condition
For an element \(b\) to be a square root of another element \(a\) in \(G\), the condition \(b^2 = a\) must hold. Using the definition from Step 1, this implies \(b^2 = g^k\), and we want to find how many such \(b\) can exist.
03
Use Group Order Properties
In a cyclic group generated by \(g\) with order \(n\), any element \(b\) is of the form \(g^m\). The square condition \((g^m)^2 = g^k\) simplifies to \(g^{2m} = g^k\). This implies \(2m \equiv k \mod n\).
04
Analyze Possible Values for m
From \(2m \equiv k \mod n\), we need to determine the possible integer values of \(m\). If this congruence has solutions, it generally has at most two solutions for \(m\), namely because the maximal degree is 2. Hence, there can be at most two distinct values for \(m\) that satisfy this congruence equation.
05
Conclusion for Part (i)
By the analysis from Step 4, any element in a cyclic group can have at most two distinct square roots since the congruence equation for square root conditions gives at most two solutions. Therefore, part (i) is proved.
06
Find a Non-cyclic Group
Consider the Klein four-group \(V_4 = \{e, a, b, c\}\) with the operation being addition modulo 2. \(V_4\) is not cyclic because no single element can generate all the remaining ones.
07
Construct Counterexample
In the Klein four-group, consider the element \(e\) which is the identity. Each element in \(V_4\) is its own inverse, thus \(b^2 = e\) for each \(b\ in \ \{e, a, b, c\}\). Therefore, \(e\) has four square roots, contradicting the result in cyclic groups.
Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!
-
Full Textbook Solutions
Get detailed explanations and key concepts
-
Unlimited Al creation
Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...
-
Ads-free access
To over 500 millions flashcards
-
Money-back guarantee
We refund you if you fail your exam.
Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with Vaia!
Key Concepts
These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.
Square Roots in Groups
In mathematics, particularly in group theory, the concept of a square root is slightly different than what we are typically used to with numbers. Here, we're dealing with elements of a group, which is a set equipped with a specific operation that combines two elements to form another element in the set. The group operation need not be multiplication of numbers, even though it's often written in a multiplication-like way.When we say an element \(b\) is a square root of another element \(a\), we mean that when \(b\) is "squared" (in terms of the group operation), the result is \(a\). Mathematically, this is expressed as the equation \(b^2 = a\). Now, this isn't always as simple as it sounds. - A cyclic group, for example, is a group where all the elements can be represented as powers of a single element, referred to as the generator. This unique structure results in each element having distinct possible square roots.- Depending on the particular properties of the group, the number of square roots for any element can vary, but in cyclic groups, no element can have more than two square roots.- Consideration of the group's structure and element relationships is key to understanding the existence and nature of these square roots.
Group Theory
Group theory is a rich field within abstract algebra and an essential area of study in mathematics. It’s the study of algebraic structures known as groups. A group consists of a set and a binary operation that satisfies four primary properties: closure, associativity, the existence of an identity element, and the presence of inverses. Groups are used to examine symmetry in mathematical structures and offer a powerful framework for understanding mathematical concepts.Here's a closer look at what makes up a group:
- Closure: If you take any two elements in the group and perform the group operation, the result is also in the group.
- Associativity: Changing the grouping of the operations does not change the result. For example, \((a \cdot b) \cdot c = a \cdot (b \cdot c)\).
- Identity Element: There is an element within the group that, when combined with any element in the group, leaves that element unchanged. This is akin to zero in addition or one in multiplication.
- Inverses: Each element in the group has another element within the group that, when combined, results in the identity element.
Non-Cyclic Groups
Not all groups are cyclic, meaning they cannot be generated from a single element. Non-cyclic groups are those in which no single element can be used to express all group members through its powers. This fact introduces a variety of new behaviors within groups that differ significantly from cyclic ones.- A classic example of a non-cyclic group is the Klein four-group \(V_4\), which consists of four elements \(\{e, a, b, c\}\). Interestingly, \(V_4\) is an Abelian group, meaning that the order of operations does not affect the outcome (e.g., \(a + b = b + a\)). However, unlike cyclic groups, no element in \(V_4\) can generate the entire group.In these non-cyclic groups, the behavior of square roots of elements can be quite different:- As demonstrated in the problem, an element in a non-cyclic group may have more than two square roots. For instance, in the group \(V_4\), every element is its own inverse, implying that each element squared yields the identity element \(e\). Therefore, \(e\) has four different square roots in \(V_4\), highlighting the departure from cyclic group behaviors.Non-cyclic groups enrich group theory by offering different types of structure and symmetry, encouraging deeper exploration into how elements interact within a group.