Question

Discuss carrier-mediated transport. How could you experimentally distinguish between the different types of carrier-mediated transport?

Short answer

Carrier-mediated transport is an essential process in cells where transport proteins facilitate the movement of molecules across the cell membrane. There are three types: facilitated diffusion, primary active transport, and secondary active transport. Facilitated diffusion is passive, transporting molecules down their concentration gradient without energy input. Primary active transport uses ATP to move molecules against their concentration gradient. Secondary active transport, or cotransport, couples the transport of one molecule against its concentration gradient to another molecule moving down its gradient without ATP hydrolysis. To experimentally distinguish between these types: 1. Test the effect of ATP depletion, affecting only primary active transport. 2. Examine the effect of altering ion concentrations, affecting secondary active transport. 3. Assess the effect of competitive inhibitors, indicating facilitated diffusion or secondary active transport. 4. Measure the effect of temperature, with varying effects on each type of transport.

Step-by-step solution

Introduction to carrier-mediated transport

Carrier-mediated transport is a process in which transport proteins facilitate the movement of molecules across the cell membrane. It is an essential process for the uptake of nutrients, removal of waste products, and maintaining the balance of ions in the cell. There are three types of carrier-mediated transport: facilitated diffusion, primary active transport, and secondary active transport. Each type has unique characteristics and mechanisms that allow it to transport molecules across the membrane.

Facilitated diffusion

Facilitated diffusion is a passive transport process in which molecules move down their concentration gradient with the help of transport proteins. This means that the molecules move from an area of higher concentration to an area of lower concentration, without requiring any energy input. Examples of facilitated diffusion include the transport of glucose by GLUT proteins and the transport of ions by ion channels.

Primary active transport

Primary active transport is a process in which the transport proteins use energy, usually in the form of ATP, to move molecules against their concentration gradient. This means that the molecules are transported from an area of lower concentration to an area of higher concentration. Primary active transport plays a crucial role in maintaining the electrochemical gradient of ions across the cell membrane. Examples of primary active transport include the sodium-potassium pump and the calcium pump.

Secondary active transport

Secondary active transport, also known as cotransport, is a process in which the transport of one molecule against its concentration gradient is coupled to the movement of another molecule down its concentration gradient. The energy released by the movement of the second molecule drives the transport of the first molecule, without the need for ATP hydrolysis. One example of secondary active transport is the sodium-glucose symporter found in the intestine and kidney cells.

Experimentally distinguishing between carrier-mediated transport types

To experimentally distinguish between the three types of carrier-mediated transport, several methods can be employed: 1. Testing the effect of ATP depletion: Since primary active transport relies on ATP as an energy source, inhibiting ATP production (e.g., by using metabolic inhibitors or anoxia) would cause the transport rate to decrease or stop in primary active transport. In contrast, facilitated diffusion and secondary active transport would not be affected. 2. Examining the effect of altering ion concentrations: Changing the ion concentration gradient in the cell membrane would directly affect secondary active transport, but not facilitated diffusion or primary active transport. 3. Assessing the effect of competitive inhibitors: Molecules that bind to transport proteins and compete with the transported substrate can be used to evaluate the mechanism of transport. If competitive inhibition alters the transport rate, it suggests that the process relies on specific binding sites, which is characteristic of facilitated diffusion and secondary active transport. 4. Measuring the effect of temperature: Facilitated diffusion and carrier-mediated active transport should be affected by temperature, as higher temperatures increase the rate of molecular movement and protein function. However, the effect of temperature on the rate for each type of transport should be different, as facilitated diffusion is a passive process, while primary and secondary active transport require energy transduction.