Question

Assuming that an animal uses a catabolic pathway that produces organic products, such as lactic acid or propionic acid, compare the pros and cons of retaining or excreting the organic molecules.

Short answer

Retaining these organic molecules provides an internal reserve of nutrients that can be re-converted into glucose or used in synthesizing other complex biomolecules. However, their accumulation could lead to metabolic disorders like acidosis. On the other hand, excreting these acids helps maintain the body's pH balance and prevents metabolite build-up. But, continuous excretion could lead to energy waste, potentially exposing the body to energy deficiency.

Step-by-step solution

Understanding Catabolic Pathways

Catabolic pathways refer to the set of biological reactions that break down molecules into smaller units. In the case of animals, these pathways can lead to the formation of organic acids like lactic acid or propionic acid. Lactic acid is produced during the breakdown of glucose in the absence of oxygen (anaerobic respiration), while propionic acid is a byproduct of the catabolic pathway of some amino acids.

Pros of Retaining the Organic Molecules

Retention of these organic acids provide an internal reserve of nutrients that could be useful in times of energy demand. They could be re-converted into glucose through the Cori cycle (gluconeogenesis). Furthermore, these organic molecules could be used to synthesize other complex biomolecules required by the animal's body.

Cons of Retaining the Organic Molecules

However, the accumulated organic acids, if not properly managed, may lead to metabolic acidosis which is a condition characterized by low pH in body fluids and tissues and can potentially be fatal. Also, too much lactic acid can lead to a condition called lactic acidosis, resulting in nausea, fatigue, and muscle weakness.

Pros of Excreting the Organic Molecules

Excreting these acids helps to maintain the body's pH balance. It also prevents the build-up of potentially harmful metabolites in the body.

Cons of Excreting the Organic Molecules

However, continuous excretion might lead to a waste of energy-rich compounds which could have been recycled by the body. This may expose the body to energy deficiency in times of high-energy demand.

Key concepts

Lactic Acid Metabolism

Lactic acid metabolism plays a crucial role in how the body manages anaerobic conditions. During high-intensity activities, when oxygen becomes scarce, the body relies on anaerobic respiration. This involves the conversion of glucose into lactic acid. While this process allows for quick ATP production, essential for immediate energy, it can accumulate lactic acid in muscles, leading to fatigue and soreness.
However, lactic acid is not merely a waste product. It can be recycled through the Cori cycle, where it's transported to the liver and converted back into glucose. This process is a fantastic example of how the body reuses byproducts to fuel further activity, especially during prolonged physical exertion.

Anaerobic Respiration

Anaerobic respiration is a type of respiration used by animals during intense physical activities when oxygen levels are low. Unlike aerobic respiration, which fully oxidizes glucose to carbon dioxide and water, anaerobic respiration only partially oxidizes glucose, resulting in byproducts like lactic acid.
The advantage of anaerobic respiration is its ability to rapidly produce ATP, giving a quick energy burst. However, this comes with drawbacks:

• It produces far less energy compared to aerobic respiration.
• The accumulation of lactic acid can create muscle discomfort.

Despite these disadvantages, anaerobic metabolism is vital for survival, particularly in energy-demanding situations or when an immediate energy boost is required.

Metabolic Acidosis

Metabolic acidosis arises when there's an excess of acid in the body due to either elevated acid production or reduced acid excretion. In the context of lactic acid metabolism, excessive production can lead to lactic acidosis, a specific type of metabolic acidosis.
Metabolic acidosis can manifest in various symptoms such as:

• Fatigue
• Nausea
• Muscle weakness
• In severe cases, confusion and difficulty breathing

Managing acid-base balance is crucial since prolonged acidosis can lead to severe health repercussions. The body compensates using buffering systems, but the demand for balance underlines the importance of efficient metabolism and potential excretion of excess acids if necessary.

Gluconeogenesis

Gluconeogenesis is the metabolic pathway that results in the generation of glucose from certain non-carbohydrate substrates. It primarily occurs in the liver and, to a lesser extent, in the kidneys.
One vital substrate for gluconeogenesis is lactic acid. The liver can convert lactic acid back into glucose, which can then be used as an energy source. This conversion is essential after anaerobic respiration bouts, as it allows the body to replenish its glucose stores without relying solely on carbohydrate intake.
The beauty of gluconeogenesis lies in its ability to provide energy during fasting, exercise, or when dietary glucose is scarce, maintaining blood sugar levels and ensuring energy availability across the body.